Reactive Attachment Disorder Blog

11/12/07

Healthy shame

Posted by : Nancy Spoolstra in Reactive Attachment Disorder Blog at 05:51 pm , 348 words, 193 views  
Categories: The System
One of my biggest complaints about “the system” as it stands now is that parents are woefully unprepared for the reality of integrating attachment and trauma-affected kids, and then those same parents are further tethered in their ability to parent by a society that shuns anything remotely “outside the box” in terms of parenting freedoms.

This series of pictures recently crossed my desk. I cannot credit it to one particular source … it is one of those emails that is forwarded from one person to the next at random. I just had to share it with you, though, as few parents would appreciate it as much as those who read this blog.

signThis would be an example of what I call “healthy shame.” It is a term I first heard used by Daniel Hughes. It didn’t used to be considered punitive or illegal or grounds for being called on the carpet by social services when a parent allowed a child to feel the shame associated with a poor decision.

SPONSOR

Last year my family hosted a foreign exchange student from China. Her stories about how the Chinese schools used shame to keep the kids in line bothered even my tough old ears. A child showing up late for school one day might have to stand on the front steps of the school for several hours before being allowed to enter the building.

momIs this young man’s “sentence” unfair? Is stealing equivalent to being a few minutes late for class? Is his mom being unreasonable in hoping her son does not follow his dad’s example? For sure, this mom is thinking outside the box. Maybe her strategy will work, maybe not. Nevertheless, she is sending a powerful message of investment, hope for the future, and concern about her son’s choices. She is there … fulfilling his sentence with him. The consequence for his action isn’t just about having to stand in public with a sign—it is about her powerful message that while his choices will determine his future, she is there guiding him along the way.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Cerise [Member] Email
That doesn't sound as barbaric or painful as some of the emotional abuse used to discipline children. The Chinese schools aren't stripping their students the way Taiwanese and Malaysian schools have been reported doing or being slapped around in Korean schools. You probably wouldn't have time even if you have cable but the latest episode of Shotime's Dexter has a scene with a former teacher disciplining her grandkids when they are home alone with her i.e. at her mercy and I find that scene far more chilling than being made to stand outside for hours which in America may sound more acceptable in boot camp than in school.
PermalinkPermalink 11/12/07 @ 18:16
Comment from: Kelly [Member] Email · http://fost-adopt.adoptionblogs.com
Oh believe me...thoughts of a consequence like this crossed my mind more than a few times. I was always too afraid of what everyone else would think to implement it though.
PermalinkPermalink 11/12/07 @ 18:22
Comment from: Chromesthesia [Member] Email
I can see if it was like some folks i've seen who suggest HITTING a child repeatedly over the slightest thing.
But this.
Stealing is a serious thing that can escalate into something worse. You can't jail kids that steal as they are too young, but to keep them out of prison, having them hold a sign really isn't a big deal consider to worse things folks could do.
PermalinkPermalink 11/12/07 @ 21:08
Comment from: my2rubies [Member] Email
I choose not to shame my children (deliberately). I believe that they have more than enough of their share shame within them already. And if I, their mother, who loves them more than anyone else in the world feels free to shame them, it's a sad, sad state of affairs.
PermalinkPermalink 11/13/07 @ 19:48
Comment from: nonny [Member] Email
First of all, shame on you for posting these pictures and commenting on them without knowing their source or the stories behind them.

Secondly, assuming the pictured woman is the child's mother,the poor choice to create a child with a thief brings shame not only to her son, but to her and to her child's father as well.

Thirdly, this is child abuse. Stating that it's better to shame a child than to hit him is an unfair comparison and absolutely untrue.

As my2rubies so eloquently put it, our children have already experienced enough shame. Our job as parents is to love, protect, encourage, and nurture them; not hurt them further.


PermalinkPermalink 11/15/07 @ 06:28
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Misc

Subscribe to Reactive Attachment Disorder Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 155