http://www.omnitrace.com/birth-family.html
Reactive Attachment Disorder Blog

02/16/06

My kid is just fine...

Posted by : Nancy Spoolstra in Reactive Attachment Disorder Blog at 07:12 pm , 388 words, 132 views  
Categories: Should I seek help?
I wish I had a nickel for every adoptive parent who emphatically stated their child came home and never exhibited the FIRST SIGN of attachment difficulties. I have heard this from parents who brought home infants under one year of age, all the way up to school age kids and teens. Occasionally I hear about a child who had only been in the orphanage for a few months, or a year, when he or she is sent to the US through a hosting program or adopted outright from the orphanage. Often these cases involve children whose parent recently died, necessitating the child’s placement in the orphanage. These kids might be ideal candidates for adoption, assuming they had any kind of healthy, reciprocal relationship with their recently deceased parent. Certainly these children would have experienced loss and would show symptoms of that loss. They would need to grieve those losses in a healthy way, ideally with an empathetic and understanding new mommy and/or daddy. But it would be entirely unrealistic to assume she would bounce into a new family, appreciate her gains, and forget her significant losses, including parents, culture, language and friends. However, it WOULD be realistic to hope that she could transfer her attachment to a new family. If she had healthy attachments to her family of origin, she would have the capacity to understand how a family works. She would not be afraid to love, once she accepted the potential risk of losing a loved one again. She would know that the risk was worth the gain… as opposed to a child who never had a healthy attachment and has no idea what the gains can be!

SPONSOR


Just as parents would never assume their child is physically healthy without seeking the advice and evaluation of someone qualified to make that judgment, parents should not assume their child is emotionally healthy without checking with a mental health professional who knows what to look for. Having said that, however, do not assume that ALL mental health professionals know how to evaluate a child’s attachment, or even understand the rudiments of attachment, grief and loss and how they look in a foster child or a post-institutionalized child. Many, many mental health care providers only know how to treat HORSES--they don’t understand the complexities of zebras!

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Lisa [Visitor]
Sandra, I can't agree with you more. L.
PermalinkPermalink 02/16/06 @ 20:24
Comment from: Debi Stevens [Visitor]
Here's another nickle for you, because I am emphatically stating that my daughter never exhibited one symptom of RAD, she was adopted from an orphanage at 12 months of age after being abandoned on the day of her birth.

I don't think we need to assume our adopted children have some kind of disorder and are mentally or emotionally unhealthy simply because they were adopted and may have never known familial attachment prior to adoption.

Maybe children wouldn't have these "disorders" if parents weren't looking for a place to comfortably rest some blame. I don't know much about horses and zebras, but I know b.s. when I see it, and as an adoptive parent I am highly offended by your post.
PermalinkPermalink 02/17/06 @ 01:06
Comment from: Nancy Spoolstra [Member] Email · http://attachment-disorder.adoptionblogs.com/
If you will reread the post, it says "attachment *difficulties*", not *disorder*. I am not at all implying all adopted kids have attachment *disorder*. I simply believe that any child who is first abandoned and then languishes in an orphanage for a year is not going to reflect the exact same outcome as a child who is born to a parent or parents who want her, plan for her, and never leave her or traumatize her. Your daughter had losses and traumas that she incorporated into who she is. I am very happy for her and you that she has integrated those losses well. However, that does not negate the fact that those losses and traumas occurred and are a part of who she is. She knows, at the core of her soul, what it is like to lose someone, whether she recognizes it--or YOU recognize it--or not.
PermalinkPermalink 02/17/06 @ 06:23
Comment from: Mary Owlhaven [Member] Email · http://ethiopia.adoptionblogs.com/
Hi Nancy,
Thanks for writing this. I am sharing some of my experience regarding this on my
Ethiopia Adoption Blog today. This is an important issue.
Mary/Owlhaven
PermalinkPermalink 02/17/06 @ 08:15
Comment from: Debi Stevens [Visitor]
Pardon me, but my daughter has no losses or traumas and YOU cannot diagnose her as having any via an internet blog. (as near as I can tell from your bio, you were a veternarian, I see no other doctorates or degrees listed that give you authority to make a diagnosis regarding human beings.)

What is incorporated into my daughter is the time, love and attention we've given her since her adoption. What she knows at the core of her soul is that she is very wanted and loved and if she doesn't feel a loss, why then should anyone focus on loss or better yet why would you *want* to?? If you look for something that isn't there you'll eventually have to justify your digging, and you'll make it so.

I vehemently disagree with you that children who come from orphanages do not reflect the same outcome as children that are planned for and never abandoned. Your *opinion* is the reason why a lot of people choose not to adopt and are scared by what could happen if a child is "not their own". It is the very reason why children languish in orphanages when they don't have to.

You are perpetuating a myth and stereotype and it is simply WRONG. Its as if you have to justify your blog category and its existance.
PermalinkPermalink 02/17/06 @ 13:19
Comment from: Julie [Member] Email · http://special-needs.adoptionblogs.com/
Wow Nancy - guess you struck a nerve on this one! No where in what you wrote did I see any anti-adoption sentiment. Just an "eyes wide open" mindset. There are an awful lot of adoptive parents I know (ones who are parenting children WITHOUT attachment disorder) who would agree that parenting their adopted child was different than parenting their bio child because of the issues of loss, grief and adjustment, regardless of how the child came to the adoptive parents.

If believing that, and preparing for it through the right pre-adoptive and post-adoptive training and information makes an "anti-adoption" statement, then so be it.

Good blog-- Thanks!

PermalinkPermalink 02/17/06 @ 19:00
Comment from: Guppy [Visitor]
AMAZING(!!!), how strong of a disagreement! IMHO it proves how invaluable your blog is...

I have read of many adopted babies who recieved all the love etc. and then became very disturbed later... And even though some children don't show that FIRST SIGN of attachement issue, where do you think it becomes apparent that they indeed have some? I know that there are so many parents that wait too long to seek help. Do you think a/parents should just take their a/kids for a "just in case check up" (at what age?)?
Assesment by a qualified professional is quite expensive...
PermalinkPermalink 02/19/06 @ 10:40
Comment from: 5xBlessed [Visitor]
Guppy hits on a point that I wonder about. Our 3yo had a very rough transition and has been home about 1 1/2 years now. He has made steady improvements in the two steps forward, one step back way. We made a lot of mistakes in the beginning, but also had some luck. For instance, I was stuck in country with him for almost a month, so I did nothing but follow him around while he played, carried him everywhere, etc. Little did I know that this is what attachment experts would probably recommend. Anyway, one thing that I struggle with emotionally is the big black cloud of attachment disorder. Sometimes the anxiety of it all really gets to me. At the same time, my son seems to be doing fine and I wonder if I will do him a disservice if he senses my fear in this area?

We recently adopted an infant he had a smooth transition and you can clearly see his growing attachment, but a while back I mentioned sleep problems on the yahoo RAD list and I ended up almost an anxiety attack. It was a one week issue w/his sleep due to teething (I think) but the terror that I experienced after being told that i should be on a mattress in his room, that I have to be very concerned about attachment disorders, I should cut back on everything and just sit with him all day, etc. It was too much and frankly I don't think it was the right advice.

This is getting long, but I just want to say it is very hard not knowing and wondering how, if at all, some attachment struggles will affect my son later. The pressure that I somehow can change it all if I just hold him more or sleep with him is too much sometimes.

I think we need to seek out as much help as we can books, articles, therapists etc., but be very careful about strangers diagnosing our kids over the internet.

Sincerely,
Johnna
PermalinkPermalink 02/19/06 @ 14:15
Comment from: Kelly [Visitor]
Debi-
Face the facts. Your daughter HAS suffered a loss!! She has lost her birthmother. This woman carried her in her womb for 9 months. Your daughter heard her voice, was provided nourishment by her. She gave her life, plain and simple. To pretend that is not a loss, is just plain naive in my opinion.

I'm sure you love your daughter. Most people don't go into adoption because they hate children, but you need to acknowledge that loss, and prepare for the fact that some day your daughter IS going to have questions about her birth mother, even if she never has attachment issues, which I pray she doesn't.

I hope that if attachment issues DO come up, that you are open minded enough to seek help. I wish I had known all of this when we adopted our son!!

PermalinkPermalink 02/20/06 @ 18:48
Comment from: Sheri [Visitor]
I only read the first response from the lady who was offended by the suggestion of attachment issues in her child who exhibits none now.

I can only tell you that It's all good now you don't have any issues, but that does not preclude them from showing up later in life. If I were you I would keep my mind open, absorb the information and be prepared in case the situation changes. I haven't seen a child yet that came out of a traumatic situation that even, with the most loving of adoptive parents who does not at one time or another have some type of attachment/belonging issues from their past.

Be happy for what you have, but be prepared for anything that could come in the future.
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/06 @ 12:50
Comment from: Older Parent Adoption Blog Archive [Member] Email · http://older-parent.adoptionblogs.com
I have never been witness to such a bunch of "prophets of doom" until now!

Far be it for any of you to feel that its a positve thing that a child is not saddled with RAD, NO, you all want to go on and on about how it eventually will happen. real nice.

Its true, misery DOES love company, and you all deserve eachother, and your lot in life!
PermalinkPermalink 02/22/06 @ 00:41
Comment from: 5xBlessed [Visitor]
Debi, you are totally entitled to your opinion and it's great that your daughter doesn't have any problems. I really mean that.

Personally, I am saddened by the tone of your comments here. I think you could've stated your opinions without resorting to name calling and especially that last line, "you all deserve each other and your lot in life."

I am very happy that my toddler's attachment issues appear to be mild to moderate and I hope he continues to improve. To say anyone deserves the pain of living with a child with an attachment disorder is cruel.

Johnna
PermalinkPermalink 02/22/06 @ 05:30
Comment from: Nancy Spoolstra [Member] Email · http://attachment-disorder.adoptionblogs.com/
Richard, I very much appreciate your comments. And I am happy for you and those you helped in Europe by starting your support group. I have found that not feeling so isolated and alone is critical to obtaining any kind of success and peace as we attempt to raise these children. I would love it if ADN and your group could link up in some way. Our needs are the same regardless of our geographical location.

Nancy Spoolstra
Executive Director
Attachment Disorder Network
www.radzebra.org
nancy@radzebra.org
PermalinkPermalink 05/07/06 @ 08:18
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Misc

Subscribe to Reactive Attachment Disorder Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 95