http://www.omnitrace.com/birth-family.html
Reactive Attachment Disorder Blog

05/13/07

The Trifecta: genetics, environment, choices...

Posted by : Nancy Spoolstra in Reactive Attachment Disorder Blog at 08:00 pm , 376 words, 176 views  
Categories: Understanding attachment, Nature vs. Nurture
trifectaIn my previous blog, I wrote about five boys who were successfully “incorporated” into a wealthy white family (the Rosen’s) in an “unofficial adoption” capacity. All the boys absorbed the messages given by the Rosen’s, went on to attend college and are more solid citizens because of the influence of these people. I asked the question, why does this work for some kids, even when it is “part time” and “unofficial” when it doesn’t work for other kids who are officially adopted and live with their adoptive parents full time?


I have long maintained there are three major factors: genetics, environment, and choices. Let’s start by looking at environment.


I believe these five boys got enough positive messages during their time in utero and their first few years of life that they were able to incorporate the positive influences of the Rosen’s. While their home lives were chaotic and dangerous, I believe their biological parents still loved them and some way, some how the boys were able to develop some sense of self as a result of the environment provided by their biological parents. Because of the establishment of some sort of foundation, the boys were able to progress through all the developmental stages of life and incorporate the lessons of the Rosen family.

SPONSOR


What about genetics? And choices? They are quite interrelated in my opinion. Note that in the article, about a dozen boys made that first visit to the Rosen home. Only five became regular visitors. What was it about them that they hungered for what the Rosen’s offered? What made them choose to continue to return to an environment where, although good things were offered, there was also accountability? Did their genetic makeup contribute to their willingness to “put themselves out”? Were they genetically programmed to be more willing to “take a risk”? Were their genetics a factor in their ability to focus on the positive messages that had existed in their chaotic families of origin, rather than internalize anger and negativity because of their circumstances? I think so… what do you think?


Choices, genetics and environment… they are all part of the equation. Here's an interesting tidbit from someone who thinks the same thing...


Photo Credit

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Faith Allen [Member] Email · http://hoping.adoptionblogs.com/
I LOVE that picture! It's GREAT!

- Faith
PermalinkPermalink 05/13/07 @ 20:27
Comment from: pat johnston [Member] Email · http://www.perspectivespress.com
I agree to a certain extent. But I'd like you to read Michael Gurian's (The Mind of Boys, The Mind of Girls) newest book Nurturing the Nature: Understanding and Supporting Your Child's Unique Core Personality out just this month and consider all of the new research we have on DNA and brain studies that can tell us more about our children's core.

I'd also like you to think about the fact that individual personalities clash fairly regularly. When nature (including personality) and nurture (including personality) class, bad choices are bound to result! You and Amy were never a good psychological fit, whereas you and Beth obviously are (where Beth was not with her first adoptive family.)

Pat
PermalinkPermalink 05/14/07 @ 08:34
Comment from: CREAMPUFF_SUGAR [Member] Email
Where is God in all of this? Supreme over all, according to the Bible. When Jesus was asked why a certain man had a malady and whether it was the man's sin or his parents, Jesus responded, "Neither. It is for the glory of God". Job's response to all the horror in his life was to fall down and worship God. Even then he didn't completely get it as one can read in the last few chapters of Job.

Sometimes I find for myself that "trying to figure all this out" is not really the question I need to be asking myself, but how can I know God through this. What would He have me do?

Like everyone else, I would love to have the answer to what causes attachment in some and not in others, but I do believe that parents take too much credit when their kids turn out "well" and too much credit when their kids turn out "badly".

The best thing that has happened to my husband and I is that we have "lost our reputation" in taking on kids from a horrible background with resultant attachment issues. Many don't understand and yet I don't know how I would have grown in my faith in Almighty and Merciful God any other way.

We are not out of the woods and may never be, but I am convinced that unless I "lose my life" as the Bible says, I will never find it. This is not to say that I am a doormat, but some of my personal hopes and dreams have been set aside and I can honestly say that it has been worth it because of how He is teaching me about Himself and His patience with me through it all.
PermalinkPermalink 05/14/07 @ 09:34
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Misc

Subscribe to Reactive Attachment Disorder Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 159